Community Building

Your community is your most valuable asset for sustainable growth and product development.

Why Community Matters More Than Ever

When Ryan Hoover launched Product Hunt, he didn’t start with a sophisticated platform. He started with a simple email list sent to 170 friends, asking them to share cool products they’d discovered. That small group of early contributors became the foundation of what’s now the world’s largest community for discovering new products.

The magic wasn’t in the technology—it was in giving people a reason to come together around something they cared about. Product Hunt succeeded because it created a space where makers could share their work and early adopters could discover innovative products. The community existed to serve its members, not just the company.

This is the fundamental shift in how successful companies grow today. Instead of broadcasting messages to passive audiences, the most successful startups create communities where their users become active participants, advocates, and even co-creators of the product experience.

Communities aren’t just marketing channels—they’re sustainable competitive advantages. While competitors can copy your features, they can’t copy the relationships and culture you build with your users.

The Community-First Growth Model

Beyond User Acquisition

Traditional growth models focus on acquiring users, converting them to customers, and retaining them through product features. Community-first growth adds a crucial layer: turning customers into advocates who attract and help convert new users.

This creates a flywheel effect:

  1. Great Product Experience → Happy customers
  2. Happy Customers → Active community members
  3. Active Community → User-generated content and referrals
  4. Referrals → Higher quality users who stick around longer
  5. Engaged Users → Better product feedback and features
  6. Better Product → Even happier customers

Notion exemplifies this model. Their community of users creates templates, tutorials, and use cases that help new users understand the product’s potential. These community contributions are often more valuable than official marketing because they show real-world applications and come from trusted peers.

The Three Pillars of Community Success

Shared Purpose: What brings people together beyond your product? Mutual Value: How do members benefit from each other, not just from you? Cultural Identity: What beliefs and behaviors define your community?

Building Your Community Strategy

1. Define Your Community’s Purpose

Your community needs a reason to exist that goes beyond “supporting our product.” The strongest communities form around shared identities, challenges, or aspirations.

Figma’s community isn’t just about design software—it’s about democratizing design and helping anyone create beautiful, functional interfaces. This purpose attracts not just Figma users, but anyone who believes in making design more accessible.

Ask yourself: What larger mission does your product serve? What change do you want to see in the world? What would your ideal users care about even if your product didn’t exist?

Your community purpose should be something people would want to be part of regardless of whether they use your product. This creates a stronger foundation and attracts more diverse perspectives.

2. Choose Your Community Format

Different community formats serve different purposes and attract different types of engagement:

Discord/Slack Communities:

Forum-Style Communities:

Content-Driven Communities:

Event-Based Communities:

Choose based on how your users prefer to communicate and what type of value you want to create together.

3. Start Small and Personal

The biggest mistake in community building is trying to scale before you have a strong foundation. Start with a small group of your most passionate users and focus on creating exceptional experiences for them.

Buffer started their community with a simple blog and personal responses to every comment. Joel Gascoigne, the founder, spent hours each week personally engaging with readers, answering questions, and sharing insights. This personal attention made early community members feel valued and motivated them to contribute more.

Begin with 10-20 highly engaged members rather than 1,000 passive ones. These early members become your community leaders, setting the tone and culture for everyone who joins later.

Community Engagement Strategies

The Content Flywheel

Create systems that encourage community members to generate valuable content for each other:

Ask for Help: Encourage members to share challenges and ask for advice Share Success: Celebrate member wins and case studies
Teach Others: Invite experts to share knowledge and best practices Showcase Work: Highlight member projects and achievements

Canva’s design community thrives because members constantly share templates, tutorials, and design inspiration. The company seeds this by featuring user-created content, but the community sustains itself through peer recognition and learning.

The 90-10-1 Rule

In any community, engagement follows a predictable pattern:

Design your community strategy around this reality:

For Lurkers: Make it easy to consume valuable content without pressure to participate For Participants: Create low-friction ways to contribute (reactions, short comments, polls) For Contributors: Provide recognition, exclusive access, and opportunities to lead

Facilitating Meaningful Connections

The most valuable communities help members connect with each other, not just with your brand. Create opportunities for peer-to-peer interaction:

Introductions: Help new members find others with similar interests or challenges Collaboration: Facilitate partnerships, feedback exchanges, or joint projects Mentorship: Connect experienced members with newcomers Local Meetups: Enable in-person connections in major cities

Stripe’s developer community includes a jobs board, open source project showcases, and local meetup coordination. These features serve community members’ broader career and professional development needs, not just their immediate product questions.

Growing Your Community

Quality Over Quantity

Resist the urge to optimize for member count. A highly engaged community of 1,000 members creates more value than a silent community of 10,000. Focus on metrics that matter:

Engagement Rate: Percentage of members who participate weekly/monthly Content Quality: Usefulness and relevance of member contributions Member Retention: How long people stay active in the community Peer-to-Peer Value: Ratio of member-to-member interactions vs. brand interactions

Organic Growth Through Value

The best community growth happens when existing members naturally invite others because they’re getting genuine value. Create experiences worth sharing:

Exclusive Insights: Share knowledge and data that members can’t get elsewhere Early Access: Give community members first access to new features or content
Recognition: Highlight member achievements to their peers and broader networks Learning Opportunities: Facilitate skill development and professional growth

Seeding Growth in Adjacent Communities

Rather than trying to pull people into your community, participate in communities where your ideal members already spend time. Provide value first, build relationships, and let people discover your community naturally.

If you’re building a community for freelance designers, spend time in existing design communities on Reddit, Discord, or Twitter. Share helpful insights, answer questions, and build your reputation. Some of those relationships will naturally evolve into your community.

Community Monetization

Direct Monetization Models

Premium Memberships: Exclusive access to content, events, or community leaders Educational Content: Courses, workshops, or certification programs Job Boards: Connecting community members with opportunities Events and Conferences: Paid gatherings with valuable networking and learning

Indirect Business Value

Often the biggest value from communities comes indirectly:

Product Feedback: Deep insights into user needs and pain points Feature Validation: Test new ideas with engaged users before broad launch Customer Support: Community members help each other, reducing support costs Brand Advocacy: Community members become authentic evangelists Hiring Pipeline: Recruit talented community members who already understand your mission

Zapier’s community provides extensive user-generated tutorials and use cases that help with both customer support and sales. Community members answer each other’s questions and share creative automation ideas that inspire new users.

Common Community Building Mistakes

Building for Yourself, Not Your Members

It’s tempting to create the community you wish existed, but your community needs to serve your members’ needs, which might be different from your own. Regularly survey members about what they find most valuable and adjust accordingly.

Over-Moderation

Heavy-handed moderation kills community energy. Set clear guidelines but trust your community to largely self-regulate. Step in for serious violations but let organic conversations flow naturally.

Treating Community as a Marketing Channel

Communities fail when they feel like thinly veiled marketing efforts. Lead with genuine value for members, and business benefits will follow. Share useful insights, not product pitches.

Neglecting Community Leaders

Your most active members are your greatest asset. Recognize them, give them special access or responsibilities, and listen to their feedback about community direction. Losing key community leaders can quickly kill engagement.

Action Items

  1. Define Your Community Purpose: What mission brings your users together beyond your product?
  2. Choose Your Platform: Based on how your users prefer to communicate and engage
  3. Recruit Your First 20 Members: Focus on your most passionate existing users
  4. Create Your Content Strategy: Plan how you’ll seed valuable discussions and content
  5. Establish Community Guidelines: Clear but minimal rules about behavior and content
  6. Plan Your Engagement Routine: How will you consistently nurture and participate?
  7. Design Recognition Systems: How will you celebrate and reward valuable contributions?

Resources

← Back to Scaling Strategies Next: Go-to-Market →

← Back to Overview